News
Reporting and commentary on the policies, institutions, and movements shaping Canadian resource development.

Cost of Divestment to University Endowments
“...it seems clear that a reduction in endowment fund returns as a consequence of divestment would have material impacts on an endowment’s ability to fund a university’s key institutional goals.”

Divesting from coal will not reduce production
Pressure to sell coal mines will not result in CO2 reductions...Chinese companies would be the most likely buyers of coal mines and would be able to operate them under less environmental scrutiny, increasing the total amount of CO2…

Divestment is not a significant factor
“…Yet the financing of fossil fuel industries continued unabated during 2016-19, with 35 banks providing some $2.8 trillion in financing for fossil fuel activities over that period, including politically sensitive fracking activities. Divestment is not yet a significant…

A Bad Idea
“...universities hold their endowments in trust for students. A decision to accept lower returns in order to put pressure on oil companies would violate this trust while opening the door to various other politically motivated pressures to weaponize…

A Costly and Ineffective Investment Strategy
"Any benefits from fossil fuel divestment are likely to be non-existent. There is no basis to believe that divestment can affect the stock prices or business decisions of targeted firms. Moreover, there is broad agreement among financial professionals…

Fossil fuel divestment has ‘zero’ climate impact
“Divestment, to date, probably has reduced about zero tonnes of emissions. It’s not like you’ve capital-starved [the] people making steel and gasoline.” “I don’t know the mechanism of action where divestment [keeps] emissions [from] going up every year.…

The Divestment Penalty
“[Columbia, Harvard, MIT, NYU, and Yale] alone stand to forfeit more than $195 million in investment returns each year [if they divest from fossil fuels], without changing portfolio risk.”

Divestment reduces endowment funds
A growing economic literature finds, by contrast, that fossil fuel divestment is little more than a political statement; it has little or no effect on the targeted companies while creating additional costs and lower risk-adjusted returns for investors.

“Should Colleges Divest From Fossil Fuels?”
“...divestment is little more than financial theater. Even at its best, it would have no meaningful effect on global emissions. What is worse, divestment misconstrues the climate problem and distracts from the market-based solutions that can actually make…

“The Endowment is Not the Issue”
“For one, an endowment is not a general fund that Harvard can freely take money from. It is designed to be a long-term guarantee for the university via investment, with only small portions of it used to preserve…

“The Endowment is Not the Issue”
“While the divestment groups have centered their most recent efforts on the abstract idea that “investments should reflect [Harvard’s] moral and political principles,” some of the campaigns have also argued that divestment will help change larger issues beyond…

Frictional Costs of Fossil Fuel Divestment
“Fossil fuel divestment advocates are not unanimous with respect to identifying which assets should be divested, and there is no objective scorecard of which I am aware to determine this question. Further, as company policies and technologies evolve,…
