News
Reporting and commentary on the policies, institutions, and movements shaping Canadian resource development.

Divesting doesn’t drive share prices down, and may, in fact, leave less eco-concerned investors positioned to snatch outstanding shares.
“Some argue that divesting doesn't drive share prices down, and may, in fact, leave less eco-concerned investors positioned to snatch outstanding shares. It also means very little with big oil companies that are private (and thus don't sell…

By staying in some of those companies, we can become an active investor, engage these companies … press and push and find change.
“The full divestment from fossil fuel would in many ways be a symbolic gesture. We’re a small investor and those companies wouldn’t much care whether we were involved or not. By staying in some of those companies, we…

We are extensively relying on those companies’ products and services for so much of what we do every day
“...I also find a troubling inconsistency in the notion that, as an investor, we should boycott a whole class of companies at the same time that, as individuals and as a community, we are extensively relying on those…

Divestment in and of itself would not meaningfully impact climate change
“The majority of the Task Force concluded that divestment in and of itself would not meaningfully impact climate change”

Given the demand, capital continues to flow to carbon based investments
“Given that the demand for carbon-based fuels cannot currently be satisfied through alternative energy sources, the carbon fuel demand will ensure that capital continues to flow to carbon based investments and the Dartmouth gesture will have no real…

Given our pervasive dependence on these companies …It is hard to reconcile that reliance with a refusal to countenance any relationship
“Given our pervasive dependence on these companies for the energy to heat and light our buildings, to fuel our transportation, and to run our computers and appliances, it is hard for me to reconcile that reliance with a…

The potential for lower investment returns after divestment is real, and substantial
“The potential for lower investment returns after divestment is real, and substantial. The National Association of College and University Business Officers (Nacubo) has estimated the assets in university endowments to be $456-billion. A 0.7% decrease in the collective…

I think (divesting) simplifies the problem
“I think (divesting) simplifies the problem. By divesting of fossil fuels, I don’t think you’re doing anything to solve the world’s problems in terms of climate change.”

Fossil-fuel divestment is a fool’s errand
“Fossil-fuel divestment is a fool's errand that works against the natural preferences of the great masses. Consumers gravitate toward energies that are most affordable, reliable and ubiquitous. Consequently, U.S. and world energy demand is dominated by natural oil,…

I do not believe that a persuasive argument has been made
“Fossil fuels enable us to operate the university, to conduct research and to provide patient care...I do not believe that a persuasive argument has been made that divestment by the University of Michigan will speed up the necessary…

Any serious success of a divestment initiative would potentially endanger the lives of billions of vulnerable people.
“Because there are not readily available, and economic, alternatives to fossil fuels, any serious success of a divestment initiative would threaten food supply, global economies and political stability - potentially endangering the lives of billions of vulnerable people.”

We are not persuaded that divestment is an effective strategy by which we will become less dependent on fossil fuels
We are not persuaded that divestment is an effective strategy to hasten the processes by which we will become less dependent on fossil fuels in the near term, and because of our concern that divestment could polarize discussions…
